Wednesday, April 11, 2012

Extended Criticism of "Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God"

In the remaining comments that I make about Jonathan Edwards' sermon, I have quoted from his text, following them with critiques from the scripture, which will be written in italics.


In this verse is threatened the vengeance of God on the wicked unbelieving Israelites, who were God's visible people, and who lived under the means of grace; but who, notwithstanding all God's wonderful works towards them, remained (as vers 28.) void of counsel, having no understanding in them.

The problem for the Israelites was certainly their lack of knowledge. Hosea prophesies, “My people perish for a lack of knowledge.” (Hosea 6: 8)

Under all the cultivations of heaven, they brought forth bitter and poisonous fruit;

Because man was still dead in his trespasses under the Mosaic covenant, they did not have the Holy Spirit living within them at the time. For that reason, the fruits of the flesh were evident in their lives (Galatians 5: 19-21)
      Every human being must be transformed from within, thoroughly reconciled, according to 2 Corinthians 5: 21. Out of a man’s heart come the vile things that corrupt him; therefore, the Lord Promised through the prophet Jeremiah (31: 33-34) to give His people a new heart, one which would have God’s laws written thereon, and He would remember their sins no more. This is the message which every preacher must preach, not the arbitrary hell fire of a God who does not seem to care if we live or die.

as in the two verses next preceding the text. -- The expression I have chosen for my text, their foot shall slide in due time, seems to imply the following things, relating to the punishment and destruction to which these wicked Israelites were exposed.

Yet Jesus preached that He did not want anyone to perish. Even Ezekiel manifested the loving Heart of God the Father, in that He does not delight in the destruction of the wicked.

1.            That they were always exposed to destruction; as one that stands or walks in slippery places is always exposed to fall. This is implied in the manner of their destruction coming upon them, being represented by their foot sliding. The same is expressed, Psalm 73:18. "Surely thou didst set them in slippery places; thou castedst them down into destruction."

It is stunning that this well-versed preacher could not distinguish the audience and the speakers even in the Old Testament. Psalm 73 was penned by Asaph, one of the Levites. He denounces the wicked, but that does not necessarily indict all the Israelites. It certainly would not include Father Abraham, whom God called His friend.

2.            It implies, that they were always exposed to sudden unexpected destruction. As he that walks in slippery places is every moment liable to fall, he cannot foresee one moment whether he shall stand or fall the next; and when he does fall, he falls at once without warning: Which is also expressed in Psalm 73:18,19. "Surely thou didst set them in slippery places; thou castedst them down into destruction: How are they brought into desolation as in a moment!"

However, the Lord is slow to anger, rich in mercy to those who believe. Edwards presents the erroneous and blasphemous notion that God’s wrath, not His mercy, lasts forever.

3.            Another thing implied is, that they are liable to fall of themselves, without being thrown down by the hand of another; as he that stands or walks on slippery ground needs nothing but his own weight to throw him down.

4.            That the reason why they are not fallen already and do not fall now is only that God's appointed time is not come.

Edwards subscribed to the ruthless Calvinist heresy that all people who are elected to be saved have been predetermined, predestined from before the foundation of the world. Nothing could be further from the truth. For we are saved by grace, which we receive by faith. Salvation is as close as one’e mouth and heart. God does not wish to condemn His creatures. He wants all to come to the knowledge of salvation.

For it is said, that when that due time, or appointed time comes, their foot shall slide. Then they shall be left to fall, as they are inclined by their own weight. God will not hold them up in these slippery places any longer, but will let them go; and then, at that very instant, they shall fall into destruction; as he that stands on such slippery declining ground, on the edge of a pit, he cannot stand alone, when he is let go he immediately falls and is lost.

Man is dead in his trespasses. God has sent His Son, who bore our sins on the tree, suffering the wrath of God, which everyone of us deserves. God is no longer angry with His creation. Yet if they choose not to believe on Him whom He has sent, then they are dead already in their sins, and consigned to eternal death.

The observation from the words that I would now insist upon is this. -- "There is nothing that keeps wicked men at any one moment out of hell, but the mere pleasure of God." -- By the mere pleasure of God, I mean his sovereign pleasure, his arbitrary will, restrained by no obligation, hindered by no manner of difficulty, any more than if nothing else but God's mere will had in the least degree, or in any respect whatsoever, any hand in the preservation of wicked men one moment. -- The truth of this observation may appear by the following consideration.

1.            There is no want of power in God to cast wicked men into hell at any moment. Men's hands cannot be strong when God rises up. The strongest have no power to resist him, nor can any deliver out of his hands. -- He is not only able to cast wicked men into hell, but he can most easily do it.

God does not send anyone to hell. Those who blaspheme the Holy Spirit, who refuse so great a gift as His Son, will choose by their refusal to spend eternity dead, forever separated from God.

Sometimes an earthly prince meets with a great deal of difficulty to subdue a rebel, who has found means to fortify himself, and has made himself strong by the numbers of his followers. But it is not so with God. There is no fortress that is any defence from the power of God. Though hand join in hand, and vast multitudes of God's enemies combine and associate themselves, they are easily broken in pieces. They are as great heaps of light chaff before the whirlwind; or large quantities of dry stubble before devouring flames. We find it easy to tread on and crush a worm that we see crawling on the earth; so it is easy for us to cut or singe a slender thread that any thing hangs by: thus easy is it for God, when he pleases, to cast his enemies down to hell. What are we, that we should think to stand before him, at whose rebuke the earth trembles, and before whom the rocks are thrown down?

2.            They deserve to be cast into hell; so that divine justice never stands in the way, it makes no objection against God's using his power at any moment to destroy them. Yea, on the contrary, justice calls aloud for an infinite punishment of their sins. Divine justice says of the tree that brings forth such grapes of Sodom, "Cut it down, why cumbereth it the ground?" Luke 13:7. The sword of divine justice is every moment brandished over their heads, and it is nothing but the hand of arbitrary mercy, and God's mere will, that holds it back.

Never once does Edwards explain why we are sinners. We have broken God’s law, we have been made in the likeness of fallen, sinful Adam, we are spiritually dead, and only through the death and resurrection of Christ Jesus do we receive life, and that more abundantly.

3.            They are already under a sentence of condemnation to hell. They do not only justly deserve to be cast down thither, but the sentence of the law of God, that eternal and immutable rule of righteousness that God has fixed between him and mankind, is gone out against them, and stands against them; so that they are bound over already to hell. John 3:18. "He that believeth not is condemned already." So that every unconverted man properly belongs to hell; that is his place; from thence he is, John 8:23. "Ye are from beneath:" And thither he is bound; it is the place that justice, and God's word, and the sentence of his unchangeable law assign to him.

4.            They are now the objects of that very same anger and wrath of God, that is expressed in the torments of hell. And the reason why they do not go down to hell at each moment, is not because God, in whose power they are, is not then very angry with them;

God is no longer angry! He has exhausted His wrath on the person of His Son. He hates sin, no doubt about it. Our God is a consuming fire, and any fallen flesh in His presence would be consumed in an instant. Yet God so loved the world, that He gave His only begotten Son, that whosoeever believes on Him will not perish, but have everlasting life! We need to hear the gospel, not this despicable hell-fire preaching which has marred the American consciousness about God, His Beloved Son, and the Holy Spirit who flows about the earth,  seeking to be received in everyone who calls upon the name of the Lord.

 as he is with many miserable creatures now tormented in hell, who there feel and bear the fierceness of his wrath. Yea, God is a great deal more angry with great numbers that are now on earth: yea, doubtless, with many that are now in this congregation, who it may be are at ease, than he is with many of those who are now in the flames of hell.



So that it is not because God is unmindful of their wickedness, and does not resent it, that he does not let loose his hand and cut them off.

God has provided the Way for man to escape the sin which separates Him from God. He will remember our sins no more. But we must receive this grace by faith, we must receive the indwelling Holy Spirit, who will quicken us to avoid the wrath to come and live life everlasting through His Son.

God is not altogether such an one as themselves, though they may imagine him to be so. The wrath of God burns against them, their damnation does not slumber; the pit is prepared, the fire is made ready, the furnace is now hot, ready to receive them; the flames do now rage and glow. The glittering sword is whet, and held over them, and the pit hath opened its mouth under them.

5.            The devil stands ready to fall upon them, and seize them as his own, at what moment God shall permit him. They belong to him; he has their souls in his possession, and under his dominion. The scripture represents them as his goods, Luke 11:12.

Luke 11: 12 actually reads:

“Or if he [a child] shall ask an egg, will he [the child’s father] offer him a scorpion?

This passage Jesus preaches to demonstrate the warmth and love of God the Father, whose lavish regard for His children exceeds the apparent generosity of even the worst of earthly fathers.

Satan has no power to take anyone into dominion. At the Cross, he was spoiled and his power put to open shame, for at the Cross the law and its penalties were fully and forever satisfied. The devil ain’t what he used to be. In fact, Satan will be cast into hell along with all unbelievers who reject the gospel of God the Father.

 The devils watch them; they are ever by them at their right hand; they stand waiting for them, like greedy hungry lions that see their prey, and expect to have it, but are for the present kept back. If God should withdraw his hand, by which they are restrained, they would in one moment fly upon their poor souls. The old serpent is gaping for them; hell opens its mouth wide to receive them; and if God should permit it, they would be hastily swallowed up and lost.

This theology of Satan is based on a poorly-divided understanding of the devil’s power in the Old Testament. Then, he retained Adam’s authority, which our first parents forfeited by their disobedience. Yet by the Second Adam, Jesus Christ, we can be received once again as sons of God.

6.            There are in the souls of wicked men those hellish principles reigning, that would presently kindle and flame out into hell fire, if it were not for God's restraints. There is laid in the very nature of carnal men, a foundation for the torments of hell. There are those corrupt principles, in reigning power in them, and in full possession of them, that are seeds of hell fire. These principles are active and powerful, exceeding violent in their nature, and if it were not for the restraining hand of God upon them, they would soon break out, they would flame out after the same manner as the same corruptions, the same enmity does in the hearts of damned souls, and would beget the same torments as they do in them. The souls of the wicked are in scripture compared to the troubled sea, Isa. 57:20. For the present, God restrains their wickedness by his mighty power, as he does the raging waves of the troubled sea, saying, "Hitherto shalt thou come, but no further;" but if God should withdraw that restraining power, it would soon carry all before it. Sin is the ruin and misery of the soul; it is destructive in its nature; and if God should leave it without restraint, there would need nothing else to make the soul perfectly miserable. The corruption of the heart of man is immoderate and boundless in its fury; and while wicked men live here, it is like fire pent up by God's restraints, whereas if it were let loose, it would set on fire the course of nature; and as the heart is now a sink of sin, so if sin was not restrained, it would immediately turn the soul into fiery oven, or a furnace of fire and brimstone.

7.            It is no security to wicked men for one moment, that there are no visible means of death at hand. It is no security to a natural man, that he is now in health, and that he does not see which way he should now immediately go out of the world by any accident, and that there is no visible danger in any respect in his circumstances. The manifold and continual experience of the world in all ages, shows this is no evidence, that a man is not on the very brink of eternity, and that the next step will not be into another world. The unseen, unthought-of ways and means of persons going suddenly out of the world are innumerable and inconceivable. Unconverted men walk over the pit of hell on a rotten covering, and there are innumerable places in this covering so weak that they will not bear their weight, and these places are not seen. The arrows of death fly unseen at noon-day; the sharpest sight cannot discern them. God has so many different unsearchable ways of taking wicked men out of the world and sending them to hell, that there is nothing to make it appear, that God had need to be at the expense of a miracle, or go out of the ordinary course of his providence, to destroy any wicked man, at any moment. All the means that there are of sinners going out of the world, are so in God's hands, and so universally and absolutely subject to his power and determination, that it does not depend at all the less on the mere will of God, whether sinners shall at any moment go to hell, than if means were never made use of, or at all concerned in the case.

8.            Natural men's prudence and care to preserve their own lives, or the care of others to preserve them, do not secure them a moment. To this, divine providence and universal experience do also bear testimony. There is this clear evidence that men's own wisdom is no security to them from death; that if it were otherwise we should see some difference between the wise and politic men of the world, and others, with regard to their liableness to early and unexpected death: but how is it in fact? Eccles. 2:16. "How dieth the wise man? even as the fool."

9.            All wicked men's pains and contrivance which they use to escape hell, while they continue to reject Christ, and so remain wicked men, do not secure them from hell one moment. Almost every natural man that hears of hell, flatters himself that he shall escape it; he depends upon himself for his own security; he flatters himself in what he has done, in what he is now doing, or what he intends to do. Every one lays out matters in his own mind how he shall avoid damnation, and flatters himself that he contrives well for himself, and that his schemes will not fail. They hear indeed that there are but few saved, and that the greater part of men that have died heretofore are gone to hell; but each one imagines that he lays out matters better for his own escape than others have done. He does not intend to come to that place of torment; he says within himself, that he intends to take effectual care, and to order matters so for himself as not to fail.

But the foolish children of men miserably delude themselves in their own schemes, and in confidence in their own strength and wisdom; they trust to nothing but a shadow. The greater part of those who heretofore have lived under the same means of grace, and are now dead, are undoubtedly gone to hell; and it was not because they were not as wise as those who are now alive: it was not because they did not lay out matters as well for themselves to secure their own escape. If we could speak with them, and inquire of them, one by one, whether they expected, when alive, and when they used to hear about hell, ever to be the subjects of misery: we doubtless, should hear one and another reply, "No, I never intended to come here: I had laid out matters otherwise in my mind; I thought I should contrive well for myself -- I thought my scheme good. I intended to take effectual care; but it came upon me unexpected; I did not look for it at that time, and in that manner; it came as a thief -- Death outwitted me: God's wrath was too quick for me. Oh, my cursed foolishness! I was flattering myself, and pleasing myself with vain dreams of what I would do hereafter; and when I was saying, Peace and safety, then sudden destruction came upon me."

10.         God has laid himself under no obligation, by any promise to keep any natural man out of hell one moment. God certainly has made no promises either of eternal life, or of any deliverance or preservation from eternal death, but what are contained in the covenant of grace, the promises that are given in Christ, in whom all the promises are yea and amen. But surely they have no interest in the promises of the covenant of grace who are not the children of the covenant, who do not believe in any of the promises, and have no interest in the Mediator of the covenant.

By faith in the final sacrifice of our Lord and Savior, man can be transformed from fallen and alienated to a welcomed child into the extended family of God!

So that, whatever some have imagined and pretended about promises made to natural men's earnest seeking and knocking, it is plain and manifest, that whatever pains a natural man takes in religion, whatever prayers he makes, till he believes in Christ, God is under no manner of obligation to keep him a moment from eternal destruction.

So that, thus it is that natural men are held in the hand of God, over the pit of hell; they have deserved the fiery pit, and are already sentenced to it; and God is dreadfully provoked, his anger is as great towards them as to those that are actually suffering the executions of the fierceness of his wrath in hell, and they have done nothing in the least to appease or abate that anger, neither is God in the least bound by any promise to hold them up one moment; the devil is waiting for them, hell is gaping for them, the flames gather and flash about them, and would fain lay hold on them, and swallow them up; the fire pent up in their own hearts is struggling to break out: and they have no interest in any Mediator, there are no means within reach that can be any security to them. In short, they have no refuge, nothing to take hold of; all that preserves them every moment is the mere arbitrary will, and uncovenanted, unobliged forbearance of an incensed God.

Application

The use of this awful subject may be for awakening unconverted persons in this congregation.

We need to be awakened unto righteousness, that we may sin not. The ministry of condemnation has glory, but the ministry of righteousness has a greater glory!

 This that you have heard is the case of every one of you that are out of Christ. -- That world of misery, that lake of burning brimstone, is extended abroad under you. There is the dreadful pit of the glowing flames of the wrath of God; there is hell's wide gaping mouth open; and you have nothing to stand upon, nor any thing to take hold of; there is nothing between you and hell but the air; it is only the power and mere pleasure of God that holds you up.

How staggering and saddening that this preacher spent more time talking about hell instead of revealing the glorious person of Jesus Christ. Him God the Father sent to save, He sits at the right hand of the Father, are blessed substitute making intercession for us on this earth.

You probably are not sensible of this; you find you are kept out of hell, but do not see the hand of God in it; but look at other things, as the good state of your bodily constitution, your care of your own life, and the means you use for your own preservation. But indeed these things are nothing; if God should withdraw his hand, they would avail no more to keep you from falling, than the thin air to hold up a person that is suspended in it.

Yes, all of this fire and brimstone. Intellects like Benjamin Franklin learned to see the through this heated rhetoric. It is not the imagined torments of hell which convict, for they can be dismissed with easy disdained by learned minds. In convicting a man through his conscience, however, there a man finds that he has no excuses and no escape from the rightful and righteous judgment of a loving God who has provided a way out for man to escape from hell and be received into eternal life.

Your wickedness makes you as it were heavy as lead, and to tend downwards with great weight and pressure towards hell; and if God should let you go, you would immediately sink and swiftly descend and plunge into the bottomless gulf, and your healthy constitution, and your own care and prudence, and best contrivance, and all your righteousness, would have no more influence to uphold you and keep you out of hell, than a spider's web would have to stop a falling rock. Were it not for the sovereign pleasure of God, the earth would not bear you one moment; for you are a burden to it; the creation groans with you; the creature is made subject to the bondage of your corruption, not willingly; the sun does not willingly shine upon you to give you light to serve sin and Satan; the earth does not willingly yield her increase to satisfy your lusts; nor is it willingly a stage for your wickedness to be acted upon; the air does not willingly serve you for breath to maintain the flame of life in your vitals, while you spend your life in the service of God's enemies. God's creatures are good, and were made for men to serve God with, and do not willingly subserve to any other purpose, and groan when they are abused to purposes so directly contrary to their nature and end. And the world would spew you out, were it not for the sovereign hand of him who hath subjected it in hope. There are the black clouds of God's wrath now hanging directly over your heads, full of the dreadful storm, and big with thunder; and were it not for the restraining hand of God, it would immediately burst forth upon you. The sovereign pleasure of God, for the present, stays his rough wind; otherwise it would come with fury, and your destruction would come like a whirlwind, and you would be like the chaff on the summer threshing floor.

The wrath of God is like great waters that are dammed for the present; they increase more and more, and rise higher and higher, till an outlet is given; and the longer the stream is stopped, the more rapid and mighty is its course, when once it is let loose. It is true, that judgment against your evil works has not been executed hitherto; the floods of God's vengeance have been withheld; but your guilt in the mean time is constantly increasing, and you are every day treasuring up more wrath; the waters are constantly rising, and waxing more and more mighty; and there is nothing but the mere pleasure of God, that holds the waters back, that are unwilling to be stopped, and press hard to go forward. If God should only withdraw his hand from the flood-gate, it would immediately fly open, and the fiery floods of the fierceness and wrath of God, would rush forth with inconceivable fury, and would come upon you with omnipotent power; and if your strength were ten thousand times greater than it is, yea, ten thousand times greater than the strength of the stoutest, sturdiest devil in hell, it would be nothing to withstand or endure it.

The bow of God's wrath is bent, and the arrow made ready on the string, and justice bends the arrow at your heart, and strains the bow, and it is nothing but the mere pleasure of God, and that of an angry God, without any promise or obligation at all, that keeps the arrow one moment from being made drunk with your blood. Thus all you that never passed under a great change of heart, by the mighty power of the Spirit of God upon your souls; all you that were never born again, and made new creatures, and raised from being dead in sin, to a state of new, and before altogether unexperienced light and life, are in the hands of an angry God. However you may have reformed your life in many things, and may have had religious affections, and may keep up a form of religion in your families and closets, and in the house of God, it is nothing but his mere pleasure that keeps you from being this moment swallowed up in everlasting destruction. However unconvinced you may now be of the truth of what you hear, by and by you will be fully convinced of it. Those that are gone from being in the like circumstances with you, see that it was so with them; for destruction came suddenly upon most of them; when they expected nothing of it, and while they were saying, Peace and safety: now they see, that those things on which they depended for peace and safety, were nothing but thin air and empty shadows.

The God that holds you over the pit of hell, much as one holds a spider, or some loathsome insect over the fire, abhors you, and is dreadfully provoked:

Thank God for preachers like Jacob Harmensen, Jacobus Arminius, who emphasized that God is love, and that God so loved the world, that He gave His only begotten Son to rescue us.

Even in the Old Testament, God the Father depicts Himself as a loving Father, Husband, and savior. Jonathan Edwards is a professing a God who is not to be found in the Holy Scriptures.

[I have excised a considerable portion of Edwards' sermon at this point, as he continues to dazzle his audience with vain rhetorical flourishes. Here is the final paragraph of the sermon:]

Therefore, let every one that is out of Christ, now awake and fly from the wrath to come. The wrath of Almighty God is now undoubtedly hanging over a great part of this congregation. Let every one fly out of Sodom: "Haste and escape for your lives, look not behind you, escape to the mountain, lest you be consumed."

I do not dispute in the slightest the reality of hell. The place of great torment, the wailing and gnashing of teeth, awaits every soul who rejects the great gift of grace offered to every believer. He is love, but because He is just, He sent His Son to pay an awful price for our sins, for our trespasses which have alienated the sons of Adam since the Fall.

Hell fire preaching creates a false of image of God, as an arbitrary deity who would just as soon damn us as well as save. Scripture in the Old and New Testaments conveys the image of God as Father as well as righteous judge, who by sending His Son to die for us, fulfilled His righteous wrath and exposed His great love of us, sending His Beloved to die for us!

Hell fire preaching such as Edwards’ overwhelming missive here places more emphasis on hell and the devil than Christ. He does not even mention the Holy Spirit, but whose quickening we receive life and that more abundantly.

Edwards’ sermons are heavy with sensory imagery, emphasizing the illiterate nature of his congregations, perhaps. His cursory references to scripture betray an unlearned misappropriation of the Word of God, especially the existence of a New Covenant, which has replaced the old and faulty covenant initiated at Mount Sinai.

This sermon, well regarded as a core element of colonial literature, also betrays some of the heresies which still persist in the American religious community. A stern adherence to a pastor and his rhetoric, instead of the Word of God; An emphasis on emotion instead of doctrine, including the Person and the Finished Work of Jesus Christ; and the overwhelming pressure placed on the the power of the devil and the demands of God, listed in the Old Testament, which have been changed in the New. Jesus Himself gave His disciples new commandments, which spring from His love for us. The love of God is manifest throughout Scripture,  in that before the foundation of the World, Jesus Christ was tapped to be the Sacrifice that would redeem mankind from their hereditary, fallen state.

We need to get our pulpits out of Calvinist colonial Boston and bring them to Mount Zion, where every race can here the Good News: our sins are forever forgiven, put away from us as far as east is from west, and that God desires now to inhabit his Creation, to transform them from “Not My People” to His very flesh and bones.

No comments:

Post a Comment