In a rare showing of long-overdue bipartisanship to solve an
issue which has become a non-issue, the House of Representatives just passed
the Sunshine
Protection Act to make Daylight Saving Time (DST) permanent. This latest
legal battle has been raging for the last few years. It started during the
Biden Administration, incidentally enough, but it never made it to his desk.
Who knows if he would have signed it, since he wasn’t signing much of anything,
right?
With Trump back in office, he has lobbied for an end to the
time chances. Trump’s signature on this wonderfully bipartisan piece of
legislation would be another win and a great addition to his welcome legacy.
I am all for getting a uniform time system in place. No
matter what the reasons were in the past, the country should finally settle on
a uniform time system, one that won’t require the changes twice a year—and
all the health problems that come with it. To summarize, DST causes
disruptions to Americans’ circadian rhythm, which can unleash all sorts of
negative consequences. Every time the time changes, there’s a sudden burst of
heart attacks, strokes, and other problems. Let’s end this.
Besides, the change is government-imposed will from previous
demands, most of which were temporary when they started. Congress needs to get
this micromanaging out of our lives for good and focus on other substantive
issues, ensuring a brighter future for our country, no matter how much sunlight
is shining in the sky.
Of course, all of this clock-switching and wrangling over daylight
saving brings up the question:
Why does the United States have this strange chronological two-step
every year in the first place?
It’s all about war, and it didn’t start with us,
incidentally enough!
To be accurate, sections of Canada began experimenting with
the daylight time changes for farming and other purposes long before any war
broke out. Those efforts remained very local, though. During World War I,
Germany was the first country to implement DST. Starting in 1916, the
Central Power wanted to prolong daylight to save fuel for the war effort by
reducing the need for artificial lighting. The U.S. followed suit in 1918 with Congress’s
Standard Time Act for the same reason… but the time change was repealed after World War I.
No one died when Standard Time was restored. It wasn’t the end of America.
Everyone went about their business, including big business, agricultural
interests, and everyone else.
Daylight Saving Time resurfaced when World War II broke out,
and our country needed as much light as possible for the same resource reasons
as in World War I. We won that war, and the federal DST regime was repealed; the
United States reverted the power to states (and even local regions) to do what
they wanted, going with Standard Time or DST as they pleased.
Time waits for no man, however, and uniform standards are
essential for understanding and planning when different sections of the country
are in different time zones. Planes (they came soon enough), trains, and
automobiles faced all kinds of problems navigating the different states with
their unique times and time zone preferences. Radio broadcasts found the lack
of uniformity disconcerting, as well.
To solve this problem, Congress passed the
Uniform Time Act in 1966 (one of the few good things accomplished by Lyndon
Baines Johnson), which standardized DST for the whole country, and also
legislated when daylight saving time would begin and end throughout the year. Finally, Congress solved the standardization
problem. However, the health issues and the general disruption of changing
clocks twice a year would continue for everyone (Except Arizona and Hawaii, but
that’s another story).
Americans have endured fifty years of this springing forward
and falling back. I’m sick of it. It’s like some old relic, all coming from
wartime, an anachronism proving yet again that government intervention knows no
bounds. Times have changed, agricultural methods have improved, and everyone
has technology to light their way, whether driving to work or getting to
school. The United States has never been more energy dominant and independent,
so concerns about fuel costs and availability don’t matter anymore.
To go with Standard Time or Daylight Saving Time is now a
matter of preference. Lots of interest groups are going to be happy or unhappy
either way, so let’s put aside their discomforts.
The frustration for me ultimately comes down to the
simplicity. For centuries, Americans—colonists then citizens--didn’t complain
about the rhythm and availability of sunlight from season to season. Americans
managed; they made it work; they lived their lives in line with nature. For
what it’s worth, I don’t recall General George Washington losing any battle
with the British or President Abraham Lincoln trying to harness the sun’s power
for war, playing with Father Time or Mother Nature to ensure military victories.
If they could manage, so can we.
Now that different sections of the country have gotten used
to a certain rhythm, though, they simply don’t want any disruption. I must
admit that the opponents of making Daylight Saving Time permanent have a point:
do we want children to go to school in the morning when it’s still dark
outside? Then again, those same kids went to school when it was dark, and there
was no daylight saving time for them for decades before. Are we saying that the
kids can’t handle the change today? We have better technology, more
sophisticated methods for keeping kids safe. The United States is not facing an
energy crisis, even while contending with our worst global enemy, Iran. Trump
made sure of that.
The important point now is to stop the clock changes
altogether. It’s to get uniformity without the arbitrary time changes.
Widespread support for the current bill should shut down further discussion. US
Senator Tom Cotton, however, wants to block the bill, sharing concerns about
the darker mornings in winter.
We should note that this year’s legislative attempt would
not be the first time that the country scrapped the time changes in our recent
past. Because of yet another energy crisis (the OPEC oil embargo), President
Richard Nixon signed a law, making DST permanent for the country. However, there
was widespread
outrage (as expected) over the change. From dark commutes for the adults,
to long dark waits for kids going to school, to farmers' complaints about
shifting their agricultural operations, Nixon and Congress realized they had a
problem on their hands—plus they didn’t save that much energy to begin with!
The DST changes went back into effect, and then Congress
added a few more weeks in 2007 with the Energy Policy Act of 2005.
The American people have adapted to change before, and we really
should end this time-switching. It’s time to move into the 21st
Century. Cotton is wrong, and he should shut up about the whole thing. Congress
should pass the Sunshine
Protection Act. Hey, I wouldn’t mind if the powers that be changed the bill
to Permanent Standard Time, but the point is to make the change. Sure, there
will be some grumbling, but probably not as much, and everyone will get used to
it.
Just pick a time already!







